Case Analysis The House Of Lords - 1930 Words

Airedale26 case decided by the House of Lords, was followed in a number of cases in UK and it was pointed out that in the cases of incompetent patients, if doctors act on the basis of informed medical opinion, and withdraw the artificial life-support systems if it is in the patient s best interests, then they said action cannot be characterized as an offence under criminal law. 24 Joseph Fletcher Infanticide and the ethics of loving concern, 22 (1978). 25 JM Appel,Neo-natal Euthanasia: Why Require Parental Consent? Journal of Bioethical In 477 (2009). 26 Airedale NHS Trust v. Bland, 1993 (1) All ER 821 (HL). 51 In another case, Ward of Court, Re A27, the ward born in 1950, suffered irreversible brain damage as a result of anesthesia during 1972 and for several decades, the ward was invalid, the mother of the child was appointed in 1994 by the Court to be guardian of person and estate of the child and in 1995 she sought directions from the Court for withdrawal of all artificial nutrition and hydration and to give necessary directives as to the child s care. 2.1.3 Euthanasia in case of Mental Patients In re F (Mental Patient: Sterilization)28, the patient was not a minor, hence parens patriae jurisdiction was not available, but even so, applying the inherent power doctrine, the same test, namely, the test of best interest of the patient was applied by Lord Brandon of Oakbrook. Here the 36 years old woman was mentally handicapped and unable to consent toShow MoreRelatedMaking A New Law, The Midterm Process And The Legislative Process Essay1044 Words   |  5 Pagesthe committee reports back to the House on their amendment. The next stage is the Third Reading; this only happens if at least six MPs request it, and a final vote on the bill will be made. This process is then repeated in the House of Lords where they have a duty to scrutinise the bill before getting Royal Assent where the monarch will approve the Bill and it will become an Act of Parliament through the Lord Chancellor. However, it is possible for the House of Lords to refuse or make amendments toRead MoreModern Approac h For Liability Of The State, And Public Authorities1733 Words   |  7 PagesThe overarching guidelines to the modern approach to liability for negligence in tort go back to Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] with Lord Atkin setting out the ‘neighbour’ principle, such that one has a duty to take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which one can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure a neighbour (one who I ought reasonably have in contemplation as sufficiently close and directly affected by one’s act and omissions). However, the development of the common law approachRead MoreThe Between Parliament And The Executive Body1036 Words   |  5 Pagescontentious issue of how effectively the Parliament fulfils this role is still being debated. House of Commons The extreme theory of Parliamentary omnipotence was concisely re-stated by the Duke of Devonshire, on 5th September 1893, in a speech delivered in the House of Lords during the debates on the second Home Rule Bill. In the United Kingdom, said the Duke, Parliament (which for these purposes means the House of Commons) which is â€Å"supreme† not only in its legislative, but in its executive functionsRead MoreLord of the Flies Nature of Man1726 Words   |  7 PagesLord of the Flies: The Nature of Man William Golding’s Lord of the Flies is a gritty allegory of adolescence, innocence, and the unspoken side of human nature. Countless social issues are portrayed, however one of the most reoccurring is the nature of man. Throughout the novel there is an ever-present focus on the loss of innocence amongst the boys, shown by the deterioration of social skills and their retrogression into a barbaric form of society. Also portrayed is the juxtaposition of a cruelRead MoreThe Traditional View Of The Doctrine Of Parliamentary Supremacy1554 Words   |  7 Pages further, that no person or body is recognised by the laws of England as having a right to override or set aside the legislation of Parliament.† The Parliament which benefitted from unlimited legislative powers was made up of the Queen, House of Lord and House of Commons, hence there was negative and positive aspects to the principle of parliamentary supremacy. Positively, all Acts of Parliament would have to be obeyed by the courts. However, with regards to the negatives, it meant that â€Å"no personRead MoreApplication Of An Employers Liability1079 Words   |  5 Pagesdeals with the breach of obligations agreed by the parties when entered into the contract. Before the House of Lords in Spring v Guardian Assurance plc and others recognised the suitability of pursuing a negligence action for a poor reference the only option of an employee to seek remedy was through an action in tort for defamation which the success depended on proof of malice. In Spring, Lord Keith rejected liability of employers for references in tort of negligence. One of his arguments was basedRead MoreThe Law Of The United Kingdom1021 Words   |  5 PagesThis essay will elaborates the law making system in the United Kingdom, whilst consider the role of the House of Commons, The House of Lords and the Monarch in the law making process. In order to analysis the law making process, those content, which will be provided, are the different types of the bill and the primary legislation and secondary legislation and each of them will has the references. The different bills are included the Public bills, Private bills, Hybrid bills and Private Members’ billsRead MoreCommon Law And Equity Law1360 Words   |  6 Pagesand 13th century, a survey was conducted on tradition, custom and law under the common law system of England. This survey originally developed as court decisions. In England, the equity laws are developed after the creation of the common law. The analysis based on development of justice and is now used in the royal courts. This gives us the story of the 1066 when the England was attacked and concluded that there is no common law system, but the local court system. It is called the power of traditionalRead MoreCommon Law And Equity Laws1381 Words   |  6 Pagescommon law and equity laws are developed after the creation of the common law; the analysis based on justice launched and is now used in the royal courts. This gives us the story of the day capital in 1066 as the winner attacked in England and concluded that there is no common law system, but the local court system. It is called the power of traditional dishes such as Shires, counties and hundreds, and laws and customs cases. The foundations of the common law have known in public as customary law. InRead MoreThe Common Law System Of England1354 Words   |  6 Pagesand 13th century, a survey was conducted on tradition, custom and law under the common law system of England. This survey originally developed as court decisions. In England, the equity laws are developed after the creation of the common law. The analysis based on development of justice and is now used in the royal courts. This gives us the story of the 1066 when the England was attacked and concluded that there is no common law system, but the local court system. It is called the power of traditional